Name:
Argument Writing:
Date:
Respond to a Formal Letter
When you write an argument, you are trying to persuade your reader that your opinion is correct
Sometimes, you might write an argument in response
to something you disagree with. When you
respond to someone, you will try to change their mind by presenting your claim
and objecting
to theirs
Remember, a strong argument has five key parts: a claim, evidence, a counter-argument, a
rebuttal, and a conclusion
Many arguments are written in letter form. Here is an example of a formal letter.
Dear Fifth Graders,
February 2, 2018
We will no longer allow any
type of sports to be played during
recess. It has come to my attention
that fifth graders have been excluding
other kids from their games. In
addition, many fifth grade students
have been leaving sports equipment
in the yard, instead of putting it away
at the end of recess. You might think
that this is unfair. But, you will find
that there are other activities you can
participate in during recess, like
running laps. Sports are hereby
banned at our school.
Sincerely,
Your Principal
Imagine that you received this letter and you
disagree with it.
1. What claim would you make to object to this letter?
Sports should not be banned at recess
2. List two pieces of evidence that support your claim.
Kids will be bored at recess
Keeps them active
3. Underline one piece of evidence from the letter
that you can present as a counter-argument in
your response.
4. Write a rebuttal that will weaken or object to that piece of evidence.