The leader of the student organization argues that we must have more student participation in the administration's decision-making processes. But if her suggestion is implemented, then the next thing you know, the students will be running the school. Teachers and administrators will have no authority, and the school will no longer be a place of learning. Total chaos will ensue. We must reject the student organization's argument.
Does it commit a fallacy? Does it commit a red herring fallacy?

Question

26-02-2020
Social Studies

contestada

The leader of the student organization argues that we must have more student participation in the administration's decision-making processes. But if her suggestion is implemented, then the next thing you know, the students will be running the school. Teachers and administrators will have no authority, and the school will no longer be a place of learning. Total chaos will ensue. We must reject the student organization's argument.
Does it commit a fallacy? Does it commit a red herring fallacy?

Respuesta :

Otras preguntas

Which one of the following statements accurately represents the Celsius scale? A. The boiling point of water is 212 °. B. The freezing point of wate

Which jewish movement can be described as the middle ground between the very conservative movement and the other more liberal branches?

what happens to a reducing agent during a redox reaction?

Evaluate the quotient of 1.05 x10 to the power of 3 and 1x 10 to the power of 3

3. When written in a chemical equation, the symbols (s), (g), (letter L) and (aq), indicate whether the reaction will proceed quickly or more slowly. True

Invented a mechanical reaper that greatly increased the speed of harvesting crops Invention that allowed the ready-made clothing industry to greatly expand In

HELP??!!! Can someone check this for me? ;) QUESTION= ¿Qué hacías tú cuando tenías seis años? Write a letter in Spanish to a friend describing what you used to

Read this excerpt from Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave: After the valuation, then came the division. I have no language to expr

What three innovations played a role in creating vast changes in American society during the Roaring Twenties?

Which of the following best describes similar figures that are not congruent? A. They do not have the same shape, but they have are the same size. B. They have

akachimichael akachimichael · Answer 1 · 2020-02-26T12:11:39+01:00

Answer: This has committed a RED HERRING FALLACY, because the students to be running the school and taking over the authorities of the teachers are not part of the argument, which was to involve the student in decision making of the school.

Explanation:

Red herring is a kind of fallacy that tends to the change the structure of an argument with an irrelevant topic, so as to divert the attention of the listeners from the main argument. This type of fallacy often tend to mislead listeners to make a wrong conclusion.

Involving the student in the decision making of the school is a good argument, but the red herring fallacy which is seen has tend to divert the attention of the listeners to an irrelevant topic that is not part of the argument.

"if her suggestion is implemented, then the next thing you know, the students will be running the school. Teachers and administrators will have no authority, and the school will no longer be a place of learning. Total chaos will ensue. We must reject the student organization's argument".